← All posts

Stripe vs Polar: payments for an AI-built SaaS

Payment processor or merchant of record? How Stripe and Polar differ on tax, fees and setup, from someone who ships subscriptions with Polar.

Tommy Pham

Short answer: Polar is a merchant of record: it sells to your customers on your behalf and handles sales tax and VAT worldwide, for a higher fee per transaction. Stripe is a payment processor: lower fees and more control, but you’re the seller, so tax registration and filing are yours. For a solo founder selling software globally, a merchant of record removes the hardest non-code problem. For a business that already handles tax, or sells mostly in one country, Stripe is usually cheaper.

I use Polar for subscriptions and one-time passes on PainBase, and Stripe is part of my regular stack.

What’s the difference between a processor and a merchant of record?

Payment processor (Stripe) Merchant of record (Polar)
Who is the seller on the receipt You Polar
Sales tax / VAT collection and filing You (Stripe Tax can calculate it, you still register and file) Polar
Chargebacks and fraud disputes You Mostly handled by the MoR
Fees Lower Higher, because tax and compliance are included
Control over checkout and billing logic Full Less, within the MoR’s product
Payouts To your business bank account To your account, after Polar’s fees

Tax is the part founders underestimate. Selling digital products into the EU, UK and many US states can create tax obligations even for a small seller. A merchant of record takes that on.

How do the fees compare?

Fees change, so treat these numbers as a starting point and check the live pricing pages:

  • Stripe charges a per-transaction processing fee, plus extra for international cards, currency conversion, Stripe Billing (subscriptions) and Stripe Tax.
  • Stripe Managed Payments is Stripe’s own merchant-of-record option. Third-party analyses put it at about 3.5% on top of standard processing, and it has been rolling out gradually.
  • Polar: as of November 2026, new organizations start on the Starter plan at 5% + 50¢ per transaction, plus 1.5% on non-US cards (fees page).

The fair comparison is Polar’s fee against Stripe’s fee plus the cost of handling tax yourself: an accountant, registrations, filings, and your time.

What’s it like to integrate each?

Polar in my experience: create products in the dashboard, send users to a checkout link or embedded checkout, and listen for webhooks to grant access. Polar has SDKs and framework adapters (Next.js among them), and it handles customer portals for managing subscriptions. Fewer moving parts.

Stripe: more building blocks. Checkout or Payment Elements for the payment form, Billing for subscriptions, the Customer Portal, Tax, and webhooks for everything. More work, more flexibility: usage-based pricing, complex plans, marketplaces with Stripe Connect.

Either way, the part AI builders most often get wrong is the webhook:

  • Verify the webhook signature with the secret (never trust an unsigned request).
  • Grant access only from the webhook, not from the “success” redirect page, which anyone can open.
  • Handle cancellations, failed renewals and refunds, not just the first payment.
  • Make the handler safe to run twice, because providers retry.

Which should you pick?

  • Solo founder, digital product, customers worldwide: Polar (or another merchant of record such as Paddle or Lemon Squeezy).
  • Company with an accountant and tax registrations, or mostly local customers: Stripe.
  • Complex billing (usage-based, marketplaces, invoicing B2B): Stripe.
  • Selling digital goods inside an iOS or Android app: Apple and Google generally require their own in-app purchase systems, with regional exceptions (US storefront apps can now link out to web checkout). Check the current rules (more on App Store rules).
  • Customers in Vietnam paying by bank transfer: a local gateway. I’ve integrated SePay for this.

FAQ

Can I switch from Polar to Stripe later?

Yes, but subscriptions don’t move automatically. You’d move new customers first and migrate or let existing subscriptions run out. Keep your own record of who has paid for what, so access logic doesn’t depend on a single provider.

Does Stripe handle VAT for me?

Stripe Tax calculates and collects it, but you’re still the seller, so registering and filing in each place where you have obligations is your responsibility (Stripe offers filing help in some countries). Stripe Managed Payments is the option where Stripe takes that on.

Is Polar only for open-source projects?

No. It started with open-source funding, but it’s now a general merchant of record for SaaS and digital products. PainBase isn’t open source.

What about Lemon Squeezy and Paddle?

Both are merchants of record too. Compare their current fees and payout options for your country.


Need payments wired up properly (checkout, webhooks, access control)? I build this. See my work or get in touch below.

Sources

Contact

Let's work together. Say hi.

Open to freelance projects and remote roles. The easiest way to reach me is Upwork or email.

PaymentsUpworkpreferredWisePayoneer
© 2026 Tommy Pham