Firebase Auth vs Supabase Auth for AI-built apps
I've shipped production apps on both. How Firebase Auth and Supabase Auth compare on setup, security rules, pricing and lock-in, and which to pick.
Tommy Pham
· Updated
Short answer: pick Supabase Auth if your data lives in Postgres (including Lovable and Bolt apps connected to Supabase), because your login and your database access rules work together. Pick Firebase Auth if you’re building a mobile-first app on Firebase, need phone sign-in, or already use Firestore. Both are free for a typical early-stage app: Firebase’s basic email and social sign-in has no per-user charge, and Supabase’s free plan includes 50,000 monthly active users. The bigger difference shows up in how you protect data, not in how users log in.
I used Firebase Auth on Pocket Party (Google and Facebook sign-in across iOS, Android and web) and Supabase on PainBase.
How do they compare?
| Firebase Auth | Supabase Auth | |
|---|---|---|
| Data it pairs with | Firestore, Realtime Database | Postgres |
| How data is protected | Firebase Security Rules | Postgres Row Level Security |
| Free tier (Nov 2026) | Email and social sign-in at no cost. With Identity Platform: 50,000 MAU free | 50,000 MAU |
| Above the free tier | Identity Platform bills per MAU after 50,000 | Pro plan includes 100,000 MAU, then per MAU |
| Social logins | Google, Apple, Facebook, GitHub and more | Google, Apple, GitHub, Facebook and more |
| Phone / SMS sign-in | Yes, SMS billed separately | Yes, through an SMS provider you connect |
| Mobile SDKs | Mature native and React Native SDKs | JS SDK works in React Native, plus Swift and Flutter SDKs |
| Self-hostable | No | Yes, it’s open source |
| AI-builder support | Rare | Lovable and Bolt can connect your own Supabase project |
Check current numbers on the Firebase pricing and Supabase pricing pages before you decide, because both change.
Where Firebase Auth is better
- Mobile apps. Firebase’s mobile SDKs, deep links and push notifications work well together. On Pocket Party, sign-in, push notifications and deep links all came through Firebase.
- Phone sign-in. It’s built in. Supabase needs you to connect an SMS provider.
- You’re already on Firestore. Security Rules can reference
request.auth.uiddirectly, so login and data rules live in one place.
Where Supabase Auth is better
- Relational data. If your app has users, teams, orders and invoices with relations between them, Postgres is a better fit than Firestore, and Supabase Auth plugs straight into it.
- Access rules in SQL. RLS policies use
auth.uid()inside Postgres, so every query is filtered by the database itself. That’s powerful, but only if the policies are right. Read my RLS guide before launch. - Less lock-in. Supabase is open source and plain Postgres underneath. Your data and users can move to another Postgres host.
- Enterprise features in one plan. Firebase moves you to Identity Platform, billed per user, for multi-factor login, blocking functions and SAML/OIDC. On Supabase, basic app-based multi-factor login is included on every plan, free included (phone-based MFA is a paid add-on).
What goes wrong in AI-built apps?
With Supabase: tables without RLS, or policies that allow everyone (using (true)). The login works, but the data is open.
With Firebase: Security Rules left in test mode (allow read, write: if true;), or rules that check the user is logged in but not that the document belongs to them.
In both cases, test with two accounts: log in as user B and try to read user A’s data. If you can, the rules are wrong.
Which should you pick?
- Lovable, Bolt or a Next.js web app with relational data: Supabase Auth.
- React Native or Expo app with push and deep links: Firebase Auth is the smoother path.
- Already on one platform: stay there. Mixing Firebase Auth with a Supabase database is possible, but it adds work for little gain.
- Need enterprise SSO (SAML) from day one: compare the SSO pricing on both, as it’s billed differently from regular users.
For the database side of this decision, see Supabase vs Neon vs D1 vs Firestore.
FAQ
Can I migrate users from Firebase Auth to Supabase?
Yes. Supabase documents a migration path for Firebase Auth users. The reverse is less common.
Is Firebase Auth free?
Basic email and social sign-in has no per-user charge, as of November 2026. Phone/SMS sign-in is billed per message, and upgrading to Identity Platform (for multi-factor login, blocking functions or SAML/OIDC) is free up to 50,000 MAU, then billed per user.
Does Supabase Auth work in React Native?
Yes, through the supabase-js client. You’ll need to set up secure storage for the session and deep links for OAuth redirects.
Which one do AI builders use?
Lovable defaults to its Lovable Cloud backend and Bolt to Bolt Database, and both can connect your own Supabase project instead. Base44 and Replit ship their own built-in auth.
Not sure your auth and data rules are set up right? I review this kind of setup. See my work or get in touch below.
Sources
- Firebase pricing and Supabase pricing (checked 14 November 2026)
- Supabase docs: Migrate from Firebase Auth
- Activepieces: Supabase vs Firebase pricing and overages in 2026